Letter to Editor: County Revenue Over Quality of Life?
Dear Editor:
My wife and I purchased our home in the San Juan Estates subdivision in Spanish Valley almost 2 years ago. It’s a modest home on 1 acre of land and we love it here. What makes this place special is largely a result of what the original developers wrote into our subdivision covenants 26 years ago.
They required that no lot shall be smaller than 1 acre and only one single family home shall be allowed on each lot. By 2019 just one single family home had been built on 53 of the 56 available lots, all 1 acre or greater.
But things began to change around 2020 when the county began to approve and even promote developer applications subdividing our 1 acre lots into ¼ acre lots. Developers jumped on this and our original 56 lots have now been subdivided into 81 lots.
One vacation rental developer who lives in Salt Lake has taken the lead. He has purchased 8 lots and subdivided those 8 into 21 lots. He has already built several large vacation rental houses from the ground up, crammed together on ¼ acre lots. He has plans to build many more. Our once spacious and open feeling neighborhood inhabited by those that call this place home, is now being taken over by developers building commercial properties for profit.
A few weeks ago the planning commission approved yet another lot subdivision in our neighborhood by a 3-2 vote. Voting to deny would have taken the steam out of subdividing and building vacation rentals in our neighborhood. But their approval holds the door open for it to continue.
When I spoke, I reminded the commissioners that our subdivision had been established with 1 acre lot minimums allowing only a single home per 1 acre lot. And that the openness and generally peaceful environment those requirements created were the reason many of us chose to live here.
I was disheartened when one of the commissioners who voted to approve clearly stated that it was in the counties best interest to subdivide. He stated that it would generate additional revenue in water and sewer tap fees as well as property taxes. My guess is that none of these commissioners would have voted to approve had they been personally experiencing the traffic, noise and late night pool parties we now live with in this neighborhood.
I understand the county needs to generate revenue to pay it’s bills. And approving subdivisions which mean more houses and property taxes, especially when they’re vacation rentals, will help meet this need. But I ask the county try to do this more thoughtfully. I ask that it not be done by generating revenue from developers who are only here to profit, at the cost of quality of life for those that call this place home.
Dave Closser
Spanish Valley
