“Lunch Box” returns to Dove Creek

1987 was a year dedicated to Michael Jackson being “Bad”, Whitney Houston wanting to dance with somebody, “The Lost Boys” being found and staked, and most historically, Ronald Reagan’s visit to West Berlin, and his famous speech, imploring The USSR’s leader, Mikhail Gorbachev to tear down the Berlin Wall.
Sorry, I cannot resist this side note, but I was a university exchange student in 1979, and we had a guided tour of East Berlin, inside the wall area, when a guard in a turret actually turned his machine gun in our direction.
It was a horrible place just to visit, so imagine trying to live in its confines.
Anyway, while the world was experiencing what I have mentioned, and so much more, Paul Davis, of Dove Creek, CO, opened up his small diner, called simply “The Lunch Box”.
Little did he know that it would become an iconic part of Dove Creek’s history.
In 1995, Shelly King purchased the diner, and decided expansion was surely needed. At that time, Highway 491 was known as Highway 666, aka The Haunted Highway, so interest in this brought many a visitor inside the, now, full-service restaurant.
Unfortunately, due to illness, Shelly needed to sell his beloved Lunch Box in 2007, which became The Dinner Bell, and eventually DC Rack Haus.
In 2023, the restaurant was up for sale once again and fate had a hand in this. Joshua Robinson, Shelly King’s grandson, had moved from California (born and raised, but his family does have deep New York metropolitan roots) to Monticello.
Fate was knocking at his door and Joshua answered quickly, purchasing in October and wanting a grand opening as soon as possible.
He did not anticipate how much work needed to be done, but November 20th was the grand day.
This was not just taking on, and continuing, the legacy of Grandpa Shelly, this was an act of love for family history. At six years old, Shelly began teaching Joshua the food business by allowing him to flip burgers in Shelly’s food truck.
For 18 years, Joshua worked in the food industry, but wanted a restaurant of his own due to his grandpa’s influence.
I will be adding tidbits of history in the rest of this article, but I must get to the food; the absolutely most delicious menu items we tried out.
There are three menus: breakfast, lunch/dinner and children’s. There is so much variety, but here are the favorites:
Breakfast – Breakfast Burrito, Country Fried Steak with green chili, Hatch Breakfast Sandwich;
Lunch/Dinner – Country Fried Steak (choice of creamy country gravy or green chili), Fried Chicken Sandwich, Patty Melt, Cheeseburger, Hatch Cheeseburger, Chef or Greek Salad.
Now this list is only of local favorites, but there is so much more!
Oh, make sure you are very hungry, and want to take home leftovers; the portions are huge and at very reasonable prices.
Shelly always taught, “Good food + Huge portions + Great prices = Customers continue to come back.”
Visiting The Lunch Box gave me a day off from cooking, so we purchased four dishes to feed us throughout lunch and dinner.
First is Roy’s favorite sandwich, the patty melt, but this was no ordinary patty melt, it was a double (yes, you can order a single).
Two all-beef patties, smothered in a rich and tangy Swiss and white American cheese blend, grilled onions between toasted marble rye bread. A comfort food addict’s dream sandwich.
The country fried steak was so amazing, I actually woke up during the night craving another platter of it.
This is Angus beef, fresh not frozen, trimmed and cut down on premises. The coating is so crunchy good, any bits that fall off are quickly picked up and devoured. Several times it was, slap Roy’s hand, and “this is mine, get your own!”.
It comes with a serving of crispy outside, fluffy inside shoestring fries and green beans. Oh, but not our average, just picked out of the garden beans.
No, these are Haricots Verts, a French style green bean which contains more vitamins of the B group, vitamins C and K and minerals such as magnesium, iron and manganese.
The country gravy is creamy, smooth with a hint of cracked black pepper, so as to not overwhelm.
Dirty Fries are loaded nachos, but using shoestring fries instead of standard tortilla chips. The toppings are green chili, cowboy beans, green onions, cilantro, cheddar cheese and sour cream.
The pinto beans are purchased locally in Dove Creek and cooked up fresh in-house; pork shoulder is used for the green chili as it is more tender after roasting.
Let me tell you that a bowl of that green chili with pork, plus fry bread, would make a complete meal in itself.
However, while Grandpa Shelly did make his own fry bread, that is not an option nowadays. But hey, get some fluffy housemade biscuits instead!
But I digress, the Greek salad came loaded with Romaine lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, black olives, roasted chicken, red onions, pepperoncini, feta cheese and the creamiest, smoothest dressing.
Every bite was a new taste sensation due to the ingredient combinations the fork picked up.
Roy and I are so looking forward to going back and trying out many of the other menu items, like the burgers (1/4 lb. pounders).
One of the waitresses walked by carrying a cheeseburger plate; the burger was actually sitting out the sides of the bun and about an inch thick. My eyes popped, and you know no one was doing a 1980’s, “Where’s the beef?”, yell.
Speaking of the wait staff, the second you walk in, you are greeted with a welcoming and friendly, “Come on in, and sit anywhere you like”.
Joshua opened up the building to make it roomier, airier and the sunlight allowed to brighten up every corner.
We sat at the “Grandpa Shelly Memorial Table”, and felt honored, and yet also felt like he was there to make sure we were happy.
The staff are very attentive; depending on experience, they start at the bottom and are trained in every skill needed in a restaurant. That way, there is always someone to step in when a staff member needs off.
So, if you want really good, I mean really good food, welcoming and comfortable atmosphere, a staff who cares about your needs, then you must go to The Lunch Box.
If you want to hear more in-depth history, Joshua Robinson will not be shy about pulling up a chair and happily chat with you.
The Lunch Box, 330 US – 491, Dove Creek, CO, 970-512-0300, Open Mon – Sat, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. and Sun, 11 a.m. to 4 p.m.

San Juan Record

49 South Main St
PO Box 879
Monticello, UT 84535

Phone: 435.587.2277
Fax: 435.587.3377
news@sjrnews.com
Open 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday