La Sal residents advocate for school as board holds public hearing for possible closure

Members of the San Juan School Board held a public hearing on the closure study for La Sal Elementary School on November 10.

 

Twenty-nine members of the public joined to voice opposition to the school closure, members of the board also heard reports from district staff.

 

The study to consider closure of the La Sal Elementary School was approved by the school board at their September 8 meeting.

 

The 69-year old building currently serves eight students in grades Kindergarten through 2nd grade. Students third grade and up are bussed about 40 miles to schools in Monticello.

 

 Enrollment over the past ten years has ranged from five and 15 students, with enrollment the past three years of six, five and seven students.

 

As part of the legal process to close the school, the district has put out a notice to La Sal and Monticello Elementary parents who would be impacted by the change.

 

The formal public hearing was the last board required step before a vote can take place on December 15.

 

As part of the district presentation administrators shared enrollment data with La Sal having seven students this year. Over the past seven years the lowest enrollment has been was five last year and highest was 13 during the 21-22 school year.

 

District officials also shared that one K-2 student in Grand and one at Monticello Elementary live in La Sal boundaries but attend those other schools.

 

District staff also shared needed capital maintenance for the nearly 70-year old school totals an estimated $567,000. Those estimated costs noted a range from lower to higher end between $453,000 and $680,000.

 

Staff noted some more urgent facility priorities including roof replacement, HVAC upgrades and fire panel modernization. Also of a higher priority is resurfacing of the parking lot. While lower priorities include playground equipment and installation of a school marque.

 

District staff also presented a 10-year financial analysis showing a forecasted cost of about $200,000 with that cost rising slightly year over year with an estimated $1 million in operation costs over five years and $2 million over 10 years.

 

In a previous meeting district staff shared that per-pupil spending over the past six years is highest at Navajo Mountain with $57,895 per student with La Sal next at $50,260 and Bluff Elementary at $29,951.

 

District officials noted that while La Sal Elementary generates 27 weighted pupil units annually through the Utah’s Necessarily Existing Small Schools (NESS) funding formula-yielding about $131,490 in base state aid–the school’s per-pupil operating costs remain high due to low enrollment.

 

NESS funding provides nine additional weighted pupil units per grade level meaning the school generates 27 WPU’s annually valued at about $4,870.

 

District staff also shared that expanding grades at La Sal to include third or fourth grade would require hiring an additional certified teacher to comply with Utah literacy mandates and state standardized testing rigor. The school last had a third grade teacher in 2018.

 

14 written letters of support and 15 comments at the meeting spoke in favor of the school. Former and current residents of La Sal, business members, parents, neighbors and even students at the school spoke in favor of keeping La Sal’s doors open including student Marilyn Garcia. 

 

“This school is fun. My class is very nice. Please keep our school open. It is important to me and our community."

 

Among concerns expressed included the burden of transporting Kindergarten through second grade students on a 45-mile bus commute over an hour each way with mornings starting at 7:00 and afternoon drop-offs at 4:20 pm.

 

Parents expressed safety concerns about sending four to seven year olds on highways in dark winter conditions as well as behavior exposure of placing young children on buses alongside middle and high school students.

 

District transport officials noted that a bus aid position has been budgeted and advertised to assist drivers on the La Sal route.

 

Community and business leaders also pointed to the poor timing of the closure with growth in Spanish Valley also spilling into La Sal and in particular as the Mariana Copper Mine shared their plans to hire 200 new employees and develop employee housing in La Sal.

 

Reagan Waite, a spouse of a Mariana Copper Mine employee, questioned the timing.

 

"Closing the school just as we're preparing for this growth seems shortsighted (...) La Sal school is just 9 miles from the Mariana Copper Mine (...) this is not a community without a future or in need of a school."

 

Locals also pointed to other anticipated growth with water infrastructure improvements, housing developments and new business permits also pointed to as signs of growth in the community with school population anticipated to follow.

 

Advocates for the school also argued that the generation of Necessarily Existing Small Schools (NESS) funding of 27 weighted pupil units being forfeited upon closure weighed against the costs of additional busing expenses would make actual net district savings minimal or non-existent.

 

On top of that several parents said if the school closed they’d consider transferring their kids to Grand County Schools or choose homeschooling which would also result in less state funding for the district.

 

Parents also offered praise for the work of the school with the one-on-one instruction resulting in significant reading gains for children especially those with learning needs including dyslexia.

A local resident and former student of the school Crystal Johnson spoke out noting she professionally is an accountant.

 

"In one of my professions I am a bean counter. I do understand the importance of fiscal and financial responsibility. If the only thing that mattered were the beans, the answer would be an easy one: close the school... But you're not just counting beans. In my other professions, I am a collector of stories... Your documents... tell me that students in La Sal struggled with reading for a couple of years, but they have improved massively. Those numbers say nothing about the child with dyslexia who received extra touch and care."

 

One written letter came from Aaron Guy. Guy, a former educator and administrator and a grandparent of La Sal noted the importance of the school for the community.

 

"A school in a small community is so much more than a place where children go to learn. It is the heart of the community. It provides a gathering place, creates connection between families, establishes a sense of belonging".

 

Board members asked clarifying questions related to the district staff’s financial modeling and cost calculations.

 

Board members also asked questions related to grade expansion and how multi-grade classrooms are taught at elementary schools in the district.

 

The meeting was the second San Juan School Board meeting held in La Sal. The November public hearing was also the last legal requirement for the board before a vote on the future of the school anticipated at the board’s December meeting. 

 

The school board also covered standard district issues at the meeting. Look for that report in the coming week.

 

San Juan Record

49 South Main St
PO Box 879
Monticello, UT 84535

Phone: 435.587.2277
Fax: 435.587.3377
news@sjrnews.com
Open 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday